Thema im Gespräch

Bruch mit Österreichs Rechtstradition

mediaElement
GeorgRinger\News\Domain\Model\NewsDefaultprototypepersistent entity (uid=5088, pid=491)crdate =>protectedDateTimeprototypeobject (2017-12-13T12:25:15+01:00, 1513164315)tstamp =>protectedDateTimeprototypeobject (2017-12-13T12:25:15+01:00, 1513164315)sysLanguageUid =>protected0 (integer)
   l10nParent =>protected0 (integer)
   starttime =>protectedDateTimeprototypeobject (2017-12-14T00:00:00+01:00, 1513206000)endtime =>protectedNULL
   feGroup =>protected'' (0 chars)
   hidden =>protectedFALSE
   deleted =>protectedFALSE
   title =>protected'Thema im Gespräch' (17 chars)
   alternativeTitle =>protected'' (0 chars)
   teaser =>protected'<b>Bruch mit</b> &Ouml;sterreichs Rechtstradition' (49 chars)
   bodytext =>protected'<b>Wien.</b> Kritik am j&uuml;ngsten Urteil des Verfassungsgerichtshofes (Vf
      GH) hat der Wiener Dogmatik-Professor Jan-Heiner T&uuml;ck ge&auml;u&szlig;e
      rt: &bdquo;Ungleiches sollte auch weiterhin ungleich benannt werden&ldquo;,
      erkl&auml;rte er zum VfGH-Erkenntnis, dass der Gesetzgeber den Weg f&uuml;r
      die &bdquo;Ehe f&uuml;r alle&ldquo; ebnen m&uuml;sse. Es sei ein &bdquo;Euph
      emismus&ldquo;, in diesem Entscheid den Ausdruck einer &bdquo;Rechtsentwickl
      ung&ldquo; zu sehen, befand der Theologe: Bewirkt h&auml;tten sie vielmehr e
      inen deutlichen und klar zu benennenden &bdquo;Bruch mit der Rechtstradition
      &ldquo;. Durchaus h&auml;tten die Verfassungsrichter anders handeln k&ouml;n
      nen, hielt T&uuml;ck fest; auch eine vom Europ&auml;ischen Gerichtshof f&uum
      l;r Menschenrechte empfohlene Unterscheidung zwischen Ehe und Eingetragener
      Partnerschaft w&auml;re juristisch m&ouml;glich gewesen. Nun sei eine &bdquo
      ;Differenznivellierung&ldquo; vorgenommen worden, die den Unterschied zwisch
      en einer Ehe von Mann und Frau und einer gleichgeschlechtlichen Partnerschaf
      t einebne. <i>Bildtext:&nbsp;Jan-Heiner T&uuml;ck hegt den &bdquo;Verdach
      t einer gewissen Anpassungsbeflissenheit der beteiligten juristischen Eliten
      &ldquo;. Foto: Uni Wien</i>
' (1243 chars) datetime =>protectedDateTimeprototypeobject (2017-12-14T01:23:00+01:00, 1513210980)archive =>protectedDateTimeprototypeobject (2017-12-22T12:23:41+01:00, 1513941821)author =>protected'' (0 chars) authorEmail =>protected'' (0 chars) categories =>protectedTYPO3\CMS\Extbase\Persistence\Generic\LazyObjectStorageprototypeobject (empty)related =>protectedTYPO3\CMS\Extbase\Persistence\Generic\LazyObjectStorageprototypeobject (empty)relatedFrom =>protectedTYPO3\CMS\Extbase\Persistence\Generic\LazyObjectStorageprototypeobject (empty)falRelatedFiles =>protectedTYPO3\CMS\Extbase\Persistence\Generic\LazyObjectStorageprototypeobject (empty)relatedLinks =>protectedTYPO3\CMS\Extbase\Persistence\Generic\LazyObjectStorageprototypeobject (empty)sortingForeign =>protectedNULL type =>protected'0' (1 chars) keywords =>protected'' (0 chars) description =>protected'' (0 chars) falMedia =>protectedTYPO3\CMS\Extbase\Persistence\Generic\LazyObjectStorageprototypeobject (1 items)00000000000024970000000000000000 =>GeorgRinger\News\Domain\Model\FileReferenceprototypemodified entity (uid=61769, pid=491)title =>protected'' (0 chars) description =>protected'' (0 chars) alternative =>protected'' (0 chars) link =>protected'' (0 chars) showinpreview =>protected1 (integer) uidLocal =>protected214338 (integer) originalResource =>protectedTYPO3\CMS\Core\Resource\FileReferenceprototypeobjectpropertiesOfFileReference =>protectedarray(26 items)uid => 61769 (integer) pid => 491 (integer) tstamp => 1513164315 (integer) crdate => 1513164315 (integer) deleted => 0 (integer) hidden => 0 (integer) t3ver_oid => 0 (integer) t3ver_wsid => 0 (integer) t3ver_state => 0 (integer) t3ver_stage => 0 (integer) sys_language_uid => 0 (integer) l10n_parent => 0 (integer) l10n_diffsource => '' (0 chars) uid_local => 214338 (integer) uid_foreign => 5088 (integer) tablenames => 'tx_news_domain_model_news' (25 chars) fieldname => 'fal_media' (9 chars) sorting_foreign => 1 (integer) title => NULL description => NULL alternative => NULL link => '' (0 chars) showinpreview => 1 (integer) crop => '' (0 chars) autoplay => 0 (integer) l10n_state => NULLoriginalFile =>protectedTYPO3\CMS\Core\Resource\FileprototypeobjectupdatedProperties =>protectedarray(empty)metaDataAspect =>privateTYPO3\CMS\Core\Resource\MetaDataAspectprototypeobject (46 items)uid => 214157 (integer) pid => 0 (integer) tstamp => 1646984904 (integer) crdate => 1646984904 (integer) sys_language_uid => 0 (integer) l10n_parent => 0 (integer) l10n_diffsource => '' (0 chars) t3ver_oid => 0 (integer) t3ver_wsid => 0 (integer) t3ver_state => 0 (integer) t3ver_stage => 0 (integer) t3_origuid => 0 (integer) file => 214338 (integer) title => NULL width => 1300 (integer) height => 867 (integer) description => NULL alternative => NULL categories => 0 (integer) visible => 1 (integer) status => '' (0 chars) keywords => NULL caption => NULL creator_tool => '' (0 chars) download_name => '' (0 chars) creator => '' (0 chars) publisher => '' (0 chars) source => '' (0 chars) copyright => NULL location_country => '' (0 chars) location_region => '' (0 chars) location_city => '' (0 chars) latitude => '0.00000000000000' (16 chars) longitude => '0.00000000000000' (16 chars) ranking => 0 (integer) content_creation_date => 0 (integer) content_modification_date => 0 (integer) note => NULL unit => '' (0 chars) duration => 0 (double) color_space => '' (0 chars) pages => 0 (integer) language => '' (0 chars) fe_groups => NULL l10n_state => NULL tx_kesearch_no_search => 0 (integer)properties =>protectedarray(15 items)uid => 214338 (integer) pid => 0 (integer) missing => 0 (integer) type => '2' (1 chars) storage => 1 (integer) identifier => '/user_upload/subportale/Rupertusblatt/RB_Fotos/RB_2017/RB_2017_50/RB17_50_02
                     _Jan-Heiner_Tueck_WEB.webp
' (102 chars) identifier_hash => '5f67051eb4770623cb1fa205114aa96337718ab8' (40 chars) extension => 'webp' (4 chars) mime_type => 'image/webp' (10 chars) name => 'RB17_50_02_Jan-Heiner_Tueck_WEB.webp' (36 chars) sha1 => '6b7edcf902cb8ea6e6b1103ab1f601b017a27b5e' (40 chars) size => 72138 (integer) creation_date => 1646985609 (integer) modification_date => 1646985609 (integer) folder_hash => '87bd96e6392893da5ad0ae6d82528051d6d5bbd9' (40 chars)
storage =>protectedTYPO3\CMS\Core\Resource\ResourceStorageprototypeobjectdriver =>protectedTYPO3\CMS\Core\Resource\Driver\LocalDriverprototypeobjectabsoluteBasePath =>protected'/var/www/html/eds.at.v12/public/fileadmin/' (42 chars) supportedHashAlgorithms =>protectedarray(2 items)max depthbaseUri =>protected'fileadmin/' (10 chars) mappingFolderNameToRole =>protectedarray(3 items)max depthcapabilities =>protected15 (integer) storageUid =>protected1 (integer) configuration =>protectedarray(3 items)max depthstorageRecord =>protectedarray(16 items)uid => 1 (integer) pid => 0 (integer) tstamp => 1750079500 (integer) crdate => 1398241027 (integer) deleted => 0 (integer) name => 'fileadmin/ (auto-created)' (25 chars) description => 'This is the local fileadmin/ directory. This storage mount has been created
                        automatically by TYPO3.
' (99 chars) driver => 'Local' (5 chars) configuration =>array(3 items)max depthis_browsable => 1 (integer) is_public => 1 (integer) is_writable => 1 (integer) is_online => 1 (integer) processingfolder => NULL is_default => 1 (integer) auto_extract_metadata => 1 (integer)
configuration =>protectedarray(3 items)basePath => 'fileadmin/' (10 chars) pathType => 'relative' (8 chars) caseSensitive => '1' (1 chars)fileProcessingService =>protectedTYPO3\CMS\Core\Resource\Service\FileProcessingServiceprototypeobjectstorage =>protectedTYPO3\CMS\Core\Resource\ResourceStorageprototypeobjectsee abovedriver =>protectedTYPO3\CMS\Core\Resource\Driver\LocalDriverprototypeobjectsee aboveeventDispatcher =>protectedTYPO3\CMS\Adminpanel\Service\EventDispatchersingletonobjectmax depthevaluatePermissions =>protectedFALSE fileMounts =>protectedarray(empty)userPermissions =>protectedarray(empty)capabilities =>protected15 (integer) eventDispatcher =>protectedTYPO3\CMS\Adminpanel\Service\EventDispatchersingletonobjectdispatchedEvents =>protectedarray(1240 items)max depthlistenerProvider =>protectedTYPO3\CMS\Core\EventDispatcher\ListenerProviderprototypeobjectmax depthprocessingFolder =>protectedTYPO3\CMS\Core\Resource\Folderprototypeobjectstorage =>protectedTYPO3\CMS\Core\Resource\ResourceStorageprototypeobjectsee aboveidentifier =>protected'/_processed_/' (13 chars) name =>protected'_processed_' (11 chars) fileAndFolderNameFilters =>protectedarray(empty)max depthprocessingFolders =>protectedarray(1 item)0 =>TYPO3\CMS\Core\Resource\Folderprototypeobjectsee aboveisOnline =>protectedTRUE isDefault =>protectedTRUE fileAndFolderNameFilters =>protectedarray(1 item)0 =>array(2 items)max depth
identifier =>protected'/user_upload/subportale/Rupertusblatt/RB_Fotos/RB_2017/RB_2017_50/RB17_50_02
                  _Jan-Heiner_Tueck_WEB.webp
' (102 chars) name =>protected'RB17_50_02_Jan-Heiner_Tueck_WEB.webp' (36 chars) deleted =>protectedFALSE
mergedProperties =>protectedarray(71 items)uid => 61769 (integer) pid => 491 (integer) tstamp => 1513164315 (integer) crdate => 1513164315 (integer) deleted => 0 (integer) hidden => 0 (integer) t3ver_oid => 0 (integer) t3ver_wsid => 0 (integer) t3ver_state => 0 (integer) t3ver_stage => 0 (integer) sys_language_uid => 0 (integer) l10n_parent => 0 (integer) l10n_diffsource => '' (0 chars) uid_local => 214338 (integer) uid_foreign => 5088 (integer) tablenames => 'tx_news_domain_model_news' (25 chars) fieldname => 'fal_media' (9 chars) sorting_foreign => 1 (integer) title => NULL description => NULL alternative => NULL link => '' (0 chars) showinpreview => 1 (integer) crop => '' (0 chars) autoplay => 0 (integer) l10n_state => NULL missing => 0 (integer) type => '2' (1 chars) storage => 1 (integer) identifier => '/user_upload/subportale/Rupertusblatt/RB_Fotos/RB_2017/RB_2017_50/RB17_50_02
                  _Jan-Heiner_Tueck_WEB.webp
' (102 chars) identifier_hash => '5f67051eb4770623cb1fa205114aa96337718ab8' (40 chars) extension => 'webp' (4 chars) mime_type => 'image/webp' (10 chars) name => 'RB17_50_02_Jan-Heiner_Tueck_WEB.webp' (36 chars) sha1 => '6b7edcf902cb8ea6e6b1103ab1f601b017a27b5e' (40 chars) size => 72138 (integer) creation_date => 1646985609 (integer) modification_date => 1646985609 (integer) folder_hash => '87bd96e6392893da5ad0ae6d82528051d6d5bbd9' (40 chars) t3_origuid => 0 (integer) file => 214338 (integer) width => 1300 (integer) height => 867 (integer) categories => 0 (integer) visible => 1 (integer) status => '' (0 chars) keywords => NULL caption => NULL creator_tool => '' (0 chars) download_name => '' (0 chars) creator => '' (0 chars) publisher => '' (0 chars) source => '' (0 chars) copyright => NULL location_country => '' (0 chars) location_region => '' (0 chars) location_city => '' (0 chars) latitude => '0.00000000000000' (16 chars) longitude => '0.00000000000000' (16 chars) ranking => 0 (integer) content_creation_date => 0 (integer) content_modification_date => 0 (integer) note => NULL unit => '' (0 chars) duration => 0 (double) color_space => '' (0 chars) pages => 0 (integer) language => '' (0 chars) fe_groups => NULL tx_kesearch_no_search => 0 (integer) metadata_uid => 214157 (integer)
modifieduid =>protected61769 (integer) _localizedUid =>protected61769 (integer)modified_languageUid =>protected0 (integer)modified_versionedUid =>protected61769 (integer)modifiedpid =>protected491 (integer)
falMediaPreviews =>protectedNULL falMediaNonPreviews =>protectedNULL internalurl =>protected'' (0 chars) externalurl =>protected'' (0 chars) istopnews =>protectedFALSE contentElements =>protectedTYPO3\CMS\Extbase\Persistence\Generic\LazyObjectStorageprototypeobject (empty)tags =>protectedTYPO3\CMS\Extbase\Persistence\Generic\LazyObjectStorageprototypeobject (empty)pathSegment =>protected'thema-im-gespraech-81' (21 chars) editlock =>protected0 (integer) importId =>protected'' (0 chars) importSource =>protected'' (0 chars) sorting =>protected288000 (integer) notes =>protected'' (0 chars) uid =>protected5088 (integer) _localizedUid =>protected5088 (integer)modified_languageUid =>protected0 (integer)modified_versionedUid =>protected5088 (integer)modifiedpid =>protected491 (integer)

Wien. Kritik am jüngsten Urteil des Verfassungsgerichtshofes (VfGH) hat der Wiener Dogmatik-Professor Jan-Heiner Tück geäußert: „Ungleiches sollte auch weiterhin ungleich benannt werden“, erklärte er zum VfGH-Erkenntnis, dass der Gesetzgeber den Weg für die „Ehe für alle“ ebnen müsse. Es sei ein „Euphemismus“, in diesem Entscheid den Ausdruck einer „Rechtsentwicklung“ zu sehen, befand der Theologe: Bewirkt hätten sie vielmehr einen deutlichen und klar zu benennenden „Bruch mit der Rechtstradition“. Durchaus hätten die Verfassungsrichter anders handeln können, hielt Tück fest; auch eine vom Europäischen Gerichtshof für Menschenrechte empfohlene Unterscheidung zwischen Ehe und Eingetragener Partnerschaft wäre juristisch möglich gewesen. Nun sei eine „Differenznivellierung“ vorgenommen worden, die den Unterschied zwischen einer Ehe von Mann und Frau und einer gleichgeschlechtlichen Partnerschaft einebne.

 

Bildtext: Jan-Heiner Tück hegt den „Verdacht einer gewissen Anpassungsbeflissenheit der beteiligten juristischen Eliten“. Foto: Uni Wien

EDS Logo

Ihr Browser oder dessen Version ist veraltet und diese Seite damit nicht darstellbar. Bitte besuchen Sie unsere Seite mit einem aktuellerem Web-Browser. Auf der Webseite browsehappy.com finden Sie eine Auswahl an aktuellen Web-Browsern und jeweils einen Link zu der Herstellerseite.